Second Mortgage Calculator

    Compare obtaining a piggyback home equity loan versus paying PMI. Find out which option saves you more money.

    Home Price & Down Payment

    %
    %

    Other Ownership Costs

    Loan Scenarios

    ScenarioWith PMI80% Loan2nd Loan
    Interest Rate
    %
    %
    %
    Loan Term
    Discount Points
    %
    %
    %
    Other Closing
    Loan Amount$380,000$320,000$60,000

    Financial Analysis

    ComparisonWith PMI80% + 2nd Mort
    Amount Financed$380,000$380,000
    Down Payment$20,000$20,000
    Cost of Discount Points$3,800$7,000
    Other Closing Costs$1,200$1,700
    Total Closing Costs$5,000$8,700
    Total Upfront w/ Down Payment$25,000$28,700
    Monthly Principal & Interest$2,278$1,919 + $573
    Monthly PMI$158$0.00
    Monthly Loan Payment$2,437$2,492
    Monthly Property Taxes$225$225
    Monthly Insurance$200$200
    Monthly HOA$0$0
    Total Monthly Cost$2,862$2,917
    Total Interest Paid$440,185$413,893
    Total Financed Cost$870,360$822,593

    Monthly Payment Comparison

    $0$750$1500$2250$3000With PMIPiggyback

    The second mortgage option saves you $47,767! Your upfront costs are higher, but your monthly payments are lower and you avoid PMI entirely.

    Complete Guide to Second Mortgages & Piggyback Loans

    When you can't make a 20% down payment, you face a choice: pay Private Mortgage Insurance (PMI) or use a second mortgage to avoid it. According to the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB), PMI typically costs 0.5% to 1.5% of your loan amount annually. But is it cheaper than a second mortgage? This calculator helps you decide.

    How Piggyback Loans Work

    A piggyback loan uses two mortgages to finance your home purchase while keeping the primary mortgage at 80% loan-to-value (LTV), which eliminates the need for PMI:

    Common Piggyback Structures

    80/10/10: 80% first mortgage + 10% second mortgage + 10% down payment
    80/15/5: 80% first mortgage + 15% second mortgage + 5% down payment
    80/20: 80% first mortgage + 20% second mortgage + 0% down payment (rare)

    Example ($400,000 home with 80/10/10):
    First mortgage: $320,000 (80%)
    Second mortgage: $40,000 (10%)
    Down payment: $40,000 (10%)

    PMI vs. Second Mortgage: Comparison

    FeaturePMISecond Mortgage
    Monthly cost0.5-1.5% of loan/yearBased on loan amount & rate
    Tax deductibleSometimes (income limits)Yes (mortgage interest)
    CancellationAt 78-80% LTVWhen paid off or refinanced
    Equity buildingNoYes (paying principal)
    Closing costsNone additionalAdditional loan costs

    Second Mortgage: Pros and Cons

    ✓ Advantages

    • Avoid PMI entirely
    • Interest is typically tax deductible
    • Building equity with each payment
    • May have lower total monthly cost
    • Can pay off second mortgage independently
    • First mortgage may have better rate at 80% LTV

    ✗ Disadvantages

    • Higher combined interest rate than first mortgage
    • Two payments to manage each month
    • Additional closing costs
    • May have variable rate (HELOC type)
    • More complex to refinance later
    • Second mortgage is subordinate in foreclosure

    When Each Option Makes Sense

    Second Mortgage May Be Better If:

    • • PMI rates are high (1%+ of loan annually)
    • • You can get a competitive second mortgage rate
    • • You plan to stay 7+ years (recoup closing costs)
    • • You itemize taxes (deduct interest)
    • • You want to build equity faster

    PMI May Be Better If:

    • • PMI rates are low (0.5% or less)
    • • Second mortgage rates are high
    • • You'll reach 80% LTV quickly (fast appreciation or high payments)
    • • You plan to move within 5 years
    • • You prefer simpler payment structure

    How to Use Your Calculator Results

    This calculator compares the total cost of each option over your expected ownership period:

    • Monthly Payment Comparison: See the combined payment for each scenario. Note that PMI payments eventually stop, while second mortgage payments continue until paid off.
    • Total Cost Over Time: The most important metric—which option costs less over your expected time in the home?
    • PMI Cancellation Point: See when you'd reach 80% LTV and eliminate PMI. After this point, the PMI option becomes more attractive.
    • Break-Even Analysis: How long until the lower-cost option saves enough to offset any additional upfront costs?

    Eligibility for Piggyback Loans

    Not all borrowers qualify for piggyback loans. Typical requirements include:

    • Credit score: Generally 680+ for second mortgage (higher than first mortgage requirements)
    • DTI ratio: Combined DTI typically under 43% including both loans
    • Property type: Primary residences are easier; investment properties may not qualify
    • Lender availability: Not all lenders offer piggyback loans; you may need different lenders for first and second mortgages

    Who Benefits Most from Second Mortgages?

    • High PMI cost markets: Where PMI rates exceed 1% annually
    • Tax-conscious buyers: Who itemize and can deduct mortgage interest
    • Long-term homeowners: Planning to stay 7+ years to recoup added costs
    • Strong credit borrowers: Who can qualify for competitive second mortgage rates

    Related Calculators

    Official Resources & Citations